# How to grow an email list of people who buy

> Pop-up offers, timing and close buttons, quizzes that feed your flows, SMS sign-up done right, and a 90-day plan for a store starting from a small list.

By The Wizel Team · Published 2026-11-19

Every flow and campaign works off the list you have, so the sign-up form is the first thing to fix, not the last. This chapter covers how to get more of the right visitors onto the list: the pop-up, quizzes, the data worth asking for, SMS, and what to do when you're starting small.

**3x** the subscribers from the same traffic when a form's sign-up rate goes from 3% to 9%

## Fix the sign-up rate first

Small gains compound. Going from a 10% to a 12% submit rate is 20% more list growth: at 100,000 visitors a month, about 2,000 extra subscribers every month, each of them entering your welcome flow.

Rules of thumb. The number to beat is the store's own past rate for each traffic source.

| Sign-up rate | What it usually means |
| --- | --- |
| Under 2% | The offer is the problem. Fix it before anything else. |
| 2-4% | A basic pop-up with a real offer |
| 6-8% | Good |
| 10%+ | What agencies aim for on the brands they run |

- **Check the traffic before the form.** Cold, broad paid traffic converts poorly on any form, and a new ad channel changes the mix, so benchmark each source separately.
- **Split by device.** One pre-launch brand converted 8% of desktop visitors and 0.9% of mobile. The fix was the mobile form, not the desktop one.
- **Don't swap the pop-up for ad lead forms.** Practitioners report those subscribers open and buy far less.
- **Judge forms on buyers, not sign-ups.** Track first-order rate and revenue per subscriber by form. A pop-up with a lower rate can bring in better customers.

The [sign-up forms guide](/blog/signup-forms-that-grow-your-list) covers reading each form's views, submits and rate.

## Build the pop-up: offer, timing, close button

Test in order of impact: the offer, then the form's size, then the submit button, then social proof, and the background image last. Most teams do it the other way round.

| Decision | Default | Why |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Offer | $10-15 off above about $100 average order; free shipping at $50-80; 15-20% off below $60 | A dollar amount feels bigger on a $250 pair of boots; a percentage scales down on a $25 bag of coffee |
| Timing | 2-6 seconds after the page loads | Instant gets a reflex close; by 8 seconds much of the traffic has left |
| Format | Full page | Nothing on screen competes with the offer |
| Mobile close | X in the top-left, plus a “No thanks” text link | A top-right X sits under the right thumb and gets tapped before the offer is read |
| Mobile trigger | The time delay; exit intent and scroll only as desktop backups | Both misfire on touch screens |
| Devices | Separate mobile and desktop forms | Mobile needs one column, big buttons and few words |
| The code | Sent by email, never shown on the form | Earns the welcome email an open and keeps the first order attributed to email |

**Make the offer beat what the site already gives.** A site-wide 20% banner beside a 25% pop-up leaves five points of reason to sign up. If everything is already on sale, headline the sale rather than stacking a token 10% on top. Brands that don't discount can gate a perk they already fund, such as free shipping over a threshold. And keep it sane: $10 off a $30 product is 33% off.

**On desktop, ask for a yes before the email.** A first step that asks “Want 15% off?”, with a decline that reads “No thanks, I'll pay full price”, works on commitment: people who click yes tend to finish. Scratch cards and spin wheels reliably lift sign-ups too. Whether they suit a premium brand is a brand call, so judge a game on first-order margin and repeat purchase, not submits.

**Where practitioners disagree: the delay.** Some agencies hold the pop-up for 30 seconds or more and keep it off checkout, on the view that the fastest buyers would have paid full price anyway. That fits higher-priced or thin-margin stores with a deep welcome offer. If you test it, compare profit per visitor (sign-ups times first-order margin times repeat purchase), never sign-up rate, which the slow version loses by design.

> Never put the discount code on the form. Say “your 15% off is on its way” and send the code in the first welcome email.

## Use a quiz only when the product needs matching

A quiz earns its extra steps when the answer changes what the person should buy: a shade or a size across many variants, a routine built from several products, food chosen by a pet's breed, age and weight. For one candle, one wallet or a t-shirt, a standard pop-up is faster. A simple test: if your support inbox gets “which one is for me?” every week, you need a quiz. The [quiz and preference center guide](/blog/quizzes-and-preference-centers) covers the build.

- **Keep it short.** A pop-up quiz asks 3-5 multiple-choice questions with 3-4 options each. A full product-matching quiz can run 5-8 questions, 60-90 seconds, one per screen on mobile.
- **Ask why they're shopping.** Motivation (performance or comfort, for themselves or a gift) tells the welcome flow what to sell. Easy questions first, personal ones later.
- **Always offer “just browsing”**, so nobody is forced into an answer that writes a false property.
- **Ask for the email after the last question and before the results.** Gate at the start and it converts like a pop-up; give the results away first and they have no reason to sign up.
- **Show one matched product** and the matched offer on the results page, not the whole catalog.

## Collect only the data a flow will use

Zero-party data is what customers tell you directly: their size, their dog's weight, who they're buying for. It's only worth asking for if something you send changes because of it. Pick 4-6 properties for your kind of store before asking anything, and name the flow or campaign that branches on each.

| Store type | Ask for | What changes |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Apparel | Size, fit preference, department | Back-in-stock by size, launch targeting, sale sorting |
| Pet | Pet type, weight band, birthday | Product matching, reorder timing, a birthday email |
| Supplements | Goal, how often they take it | The welcome pitch, replenishment timing, bundles |
| Food and drink | Taste, household size, dietary needs | Recommendations, default cadence, launches |
| Gifting | Who it's for, the occasion date | Occasion reminders, holiday opt-outs |

Save each answer as a Klaviyo profile property with fixed values (lowercase, never free text), build a segment for each answer, and target launches and restocks with it. Once the list is big enough to split the welcome flow, the test of the wiring is simple: two people who answered differently get a visibly different first email. The [welcome series guide](/blog/welcome-email-series-guide) covers what that series should say.

- **After sign-up, ask one question per touchpoint**, about one a month at most, never one the order history answers. The best goes in the order confirmation: “Who did you buy this for?” Gift buyers then get an occasion reminder next year, not a reorder nudge in 30 days.
- **Put a preference center in front of the unsubscribe.** Offer “fewer emails” before “no emails”: 2-3 frequency tiers and a 30, 60 or 90-day pause that every campaign respects.
- **Offer a holiday opt-out** 2-3 weeks before Mother's Day or Father's Day: one click to skip those emails this year.
- **Re-ask after about 12 months.** Stated preferences go stale, and when a profile says menswear but the last three orders are womenswear, the orders win.

## Add SMS as the second step, not a second offer

Ask for the phone number on the same pop-up, right after the email, as the step that activates the offer they already started claiming: “finish signing up with text to activate your discount.” One offer, one code. A bigger discount for SMS backfires: people decide the email discount is fine and stop at step one, and you end up running two codes through every flow.

- Where the number is confirmed by a reply, say “reply Y to get your code” and send the code in the confirmation text. Show it on the form and people take it and never reply.
- The form needs SMS consent wording and an honest frequency, such as “up to 6 messages a month”. The [deliverability and consent chapter](/blog/email-deliverability-and-consent) covers what to record.
- Recover numbers from email-only subscribers with a separate SMS pop-up on a later visit, never in the session they just signed up in.

SMS interrupts, so keep it for news worth a buzz in someone's pocket: a sale, a limited drop, back in stock, a shipping problem. Stories and how-tos stay in email. In flows, everyone gets the email and SMS subscribers get the text about five minutes later, so a purchase from the email stops the text. In the US, texts go out only between 8am and 9pm in the recipient's time zone, and some states are stricter.

When to start is disputed. One camp banks numbers from day one, because you can't collect them later and they're worth having by peak season. The other keeps a small store's form email-only until email brings in about $5,000 a month. If you bank numbers early, send the confirmation text at sign-up and don't leave them silent for months. What to text once you have the numbers is in the [SMS guide](/blog/sms-marketing-for-shopify).

## Your list is also your best ad data

Emails and phone numbers collected with consent are first-party data, and they matter more now that browser pixels miss purchases to iOS privacy changes, ad blockers and cookie limits. Send conversions from your server as well: Meta calls it the Conversions API, Google Enhanced Conversions, TikTok the Events API. Share an event ID with the pixel so each purchase counts once, and pass hashed email and phone so the platform can match the buyer without a cookie.

- Seed lookalike audiences from your best repeat buyers, not all purchasers.
- Exclude customers and engaged subscribers from prospecting, so ad spend goes to new people.
- Keep one source of truth for opt-outs, so an unsubscribe or deletion request reaches your synced ad audiences too.

## Starting from a small list: the first 90 days

Under about 5,000 subscribers, list growth matters more than anything else you could tune. Capture comes first, because a visitor who leaves without signing up is gone for good. A plain form live in week one beats a perfect one in week six.

| Weeks | Build |
| --- | --- |
| 1-2 | A sign-up form with a real offer, and a 3-email welcome flow that delivers the code |
| 3-4 | Abandoned cart flow, 2-3 emails |
| 5-8 | Post-purchase flow, and campaigns once or twice a week |
| 9-12 | Browse abandonment and a simple win-back |

- **Send campaigns to the whole list.** Under about 3,000 subscribers, an engaged-only segment hides you from people you paid to acquire. Add a 90-day engaged segment at 3,000-5,000 or at the first sign of trouble.
- **Send plain text signed by a person.** At this size the personal touch is your edge, and replies help a new sending domain.
- **Wait on the fancy parts:** RFM until about 500 customers, A/B tests until 1,000 recipients per version, branching flows until about 5,000 subscribers.
- **Never buy lists or import trade-show badge scans**, and skip generic-prize giveaways, which fill the list with prize hunters.
- **Consider double opt-in on a brand-new domain.** You give up 10-20% of sign-ups for a list that won't complain.

Set expectations honestly. In its first quarter, a list of 1,000 is typically a $100-500 a month channel ($0.10-0.50 per subscriber), rising toward $1-3 per subscriber a month as the program matures. Under about 3,000 visits a month, the problem is traffic, and no form fixes it. An agency taking on a small client should say so up front: the first months build the list and foundations, and revenue follows in months 3-9.

Pick one change for this week: move the discount code off the form and into the first welcome email, or move the mobile close button to the top-left. Then build what new subscribers receive, starting with the next chapter, [the email flows every store needs](/blog/email-flows-every-store-needs).

## How to set up an email and SMS pop-up that converts

1. **Pick the offer**: Use a dollar amount above about a $100 average order, free shipping or a percentage below it, and make sure it beats any site-wide banner.
2. **Build two forms**: Make separate full-page forms for mobile and desktop, with one column and large buttons on mobile.
3. **Set the trigger**: Show the pop-up 2-6 seconds after the page loads; use exit intent only as a desktop backup.
4. **Place the close**: Put the mobile close button in the top-left and add a No thanks text link under the submit button.
5. **Add the SMS step**: Ask for the phone number after the email as the step that activates the same offer, with consent wording and an honest frequency.
6. **Send the code by email**: Deliver the code in the first welcome email, sent immediately, never on the form.
7. **Measure by source and device**: Track sign-up rate per traffic source and device, plus first-order rate per form.

## FAQ

### What is a good sign-up rate for an email pop-up?

A basic pop-up with a real offer converts about 2-4% of visitors, and agencies aim for 10% or more on the brands they run. The best comparison is the store's own past rate for each traffic source.

### When should an email pop-up appear?

Two to six seconds after the page loads: not instantly, and not after eight seconds. Some agencies wait 30 seconds or more to protect margin on higher-priced products; test that on profit per visitor, not sign-ups.

### Should I show the discount code in the pop-up?

No. Send it by email. That earns the welcome email an open, confirms the address is real, and keeps the first order attributed to email.

### Should I offer a bigger discount for SMS sign-up?

No. Use one offer and one code, and ask for the phone number as the step that activates it. A bigger SMS discount makes people stop at the email step and leaves you with conflicting codes.

### When is a quiz better than a pop-up?

When the product needs matching: shades, sizes, routines, or food by a pet's breed and age. For a single product or one that explains itself, a standard pop-up is faster.

---

Source: Wizel (https://www.wizel.ai/blog/grow-an-email-list-that-buys)
Last updated: 2026-11-19