# Email deliverability for Shopify: how to reach the inbox and stay there

> Set up SPF, DKIM and DMARC, meet the Gmail and Yahoo sender rules, collect consent you can prove, clean your list, and find out why results suddenly fell.

By The Wizel Team · Published 2026-11-19

An email that lands in spam earns nothing, however good it is. Gmail, Yahoo and Microsoft now refuse bulk mail that isn't authenticated, and they judge everything else by how your subscribers react to it. This chapter covers the setup that gets you through the door, the consent that keeps you legal, the list habits that keep you in the inbox, and what to check when results suddenly fall.

**5,000** messages to Gmail in one day, and Google treats you as a bulk sender for good

## Your domain has a credit score

Mailbox providers keep a running judgment of your sending domain. Authentication, a steady rhythm and clicks add to it; complaints, bounces and mail to people who never respond take away. It builds slowly and drops fast, and flows share it with campaigns, so one careless send to an old list can drag your welcome emails into spam too.

## Set up SPF, DKIM and DMARC before you send

Authentication proves the mail really comes from you. The records live at your DNS provider (wherever your domain is managed), not in Klaviyo. Klaviyo only generates them.

| Record | What it does | Where it comes from |
| --- | --- | --- |
| SPF | Lists the servers allowed to send as your domain | One TXT record at your root domain |
| DKIM | Signs each email so receivers can check it wasn't altered | Klaviyo, when you add a branded sending domain |
| DMARC | Tells receivers what to do with mail that fails, and sends you reports | One TXT record at _dmarc on your domain |

1. **Add a branded sending domain** in Klaviyo under Settings, then Domains. Use a subdomain of your site, such as send.yourstore.com, and choose dynamic routing: you add four NS records and Klaviyo manages SPF and DKIM. Without one, Gmail shows “via klaviyomail.com” under your name.
2. **Publish DMARC at p=none** with a reporting address someone reads. Leave it there for 2-4 weeks and check that every service sending as you passes: Klaviyo, Shopify, your helpdesk, your invoicing tool.
3. **Tighten to p=quarantine, then p=reject**, once the reports are clean. Never jump straight to reject. Any sender you missed starts bouncing.
4. **Send from your own root domain.** If you authenticate send.yourstore.com, the From address is something@yourstore.com, never a free Gmail address or another domain. Point the reply-to at an inbox a person reads, because replies are the strongest good signal a mailbox provider sees.

Two traps catch people. You can have only one SPF record, so merge a new service into the existing one rather than adding a second, and keep it under 10 DNS lookups or it fails outright. And DNS changes take 4-48 hours to show up, so do this days before a launch, not the morning of it.

Once DMARC is at quarantine or reject, you can add BIMI, your logo beside your emails in supported inboxes (Gmail and Apple also want a paid Verified Mark Certificate). It's a finishing touch, not a fix.

## What Gmail, Yahoo and Microsoft require

The big providers turned these basics into rules for bulk senders, and they enforce them by refusing mail, not only by filtering it.

| Provider | Who it applies to | What you need | If you miss it |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Gmail | 5,000+ messages a day to Gmail addresses | SPF and DKIM, DMARC at p=none or stronger aligned with your From domain, one-click unsubscribe, unsubscribes honored within 2 days, spam rate under 0.3% | Since November 2025, temporary deferrals, then permanent rejections |
| Microsoft (Outlook.com, Hotmail, Live) | 5,000+ messages a day | SPF, DKIM and DMARC at p=none or stronger | Junk folder since May 2025, with rejection to follow |
| Yahoo | Bulk senders | Matching rules, announced with Gmail's for 2024 | Check Yahoo's sender hub for current enforcement |

Klaviyo adds the one-click unsubscribe header to every email; the records and the spam rate are yours. Set them up whatever your volume, because one 5,000-email day to Gmail makes you a bulk sender for good. Google Postmaster Tools shows whether you pass and what your spam rate is. It no longer shows a reputation score.

> Spam complaints are the number to protect. Google's ceiling is 0.3%. Stay under 0.1%, and many agencies hold regular sends near 0.05%.

## Warm up a new domain or account

A new sending domain or a new Klaviyo account has no reputation, and going from zero to your full list looks like spam. Most Klaviyo brands send from shared IPs, so what you warm is the domain. An account with at least 30 days of sending history can switch to a branded domain without warming again.

1. **Turn on flows first.** The first email of your welcome, abandoned cart and abandoned checkout flows reaches people who just acted, so it earns good signals at low volume.
2. **Start campaigns with about 500 of your most engaged profiles:** people who opened or clicked in the last 30 days and ordered in the last 90. Keep these early emails mostly text.
3. **Double the audience every 2-3 sends**, with 2-3 days between sends, until you reach the full list after 4-8 weeks. Klaviyo's batch-send option spreads a larger send over a few hours.
4. **Stop growing and hold for 2-3 more sends** if spam complaints pass 0.1%, bounces jump or clicks fall.

Then keep a steady rhythm. Send at least once a week. Five emails one week and nothing for the next three is the pattern filters punish. In a quiet month, send something useful rather than nothing.

## Consent: who you can email and text, and the proof to keep

Consent is a legal rule and a deliverability one: people who never agreed to hear from you are the ones who press the spam button. This is common practice, not legal advice. Rules vary by country and state, so confirm them with counsel.

| Situation | What counts as consent |
| --- | --- |
| Marketing email | A clear opt-in, separate from accepting your terms. A pre-checked box doesn't count in most places. |
| Marketing SMS | Express written consent to texts specifically, before the first one, stating how often you'll text, that message and data rates apply, and that consent isn't a condition of buying |
| A purchase | Order and shipping messages only. Not marketing consent unless they also opted in. |
| Existing customers in the UK and EU | A narrow soft opt-in for your own similar products, if they could opt out when you took the address and can in every email |

**Record the proof.** For every opt-in, store the date and time, the form or page, the region where it matters, and the exact wording the person saw, as Klaviyo profile properties. If an SMS send skips many profiles for missing consent, pull about 20 and check how each number was collected: a pop-up with consent wording carries consent, a number typed at checkout with no consent box may not. Fix the form; never force the send.

**Single or double opt-in.** Single opt-in grows faster but lets in typos and bots. Double opt-in asks for a confirmation click: a smaller, cleaner list. Use it where deliverability or legal exposure matters most.

- Every marketing email needs an honest From name and subject, a visible unsubscribe link and your physical postal address.
- Honor unsubscribes at once. US law (CAN-SPAM) allows 10 business days and Gmail 2 days, but someone who can't leave reports you as spam instead.
- In the US, marketing texts go out only between 8am and 9pm in the recipient's time zone, and some states are stricter (Florida allows 8am-8pm). Honor STOP immediately.
- Keep order and shipping messages apart from marketing. Offers inside a transactional message can cost it that status.

## Clean the list: win back, sunset, suppress

Mailing people who never engage is the most common reason deliverability slides. Providers see your mail ignored and start filtering it, including for the people who want it. The fix is a monthly routine that splits quiet subscribers into two groups: past buyers get a win-back, people who never engaged get a sunset.

|  | Win-back | Sunset |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Who | Past customers who stopped buying | Subscribers with no clicks, site visits or orders |
| When | About 90 days after the last order; 30-60 days for consumables, 180+ for expensive, rarely bought products | 180 days without activity (120 for very frequent senders), after at least 5 emails |
| Emails | 3-10 over 2-4 weeks | One, two at most |
| Lead with | Your strongest offer, not “we miss you” | One button to stay subscribed |
| No response | Move them to the sunset | Suppress after 7-14 days |

- **Judge on clicks, site visits and orders, never opens.** Apple Mail Privacy Protection fakes opens, so a segment built on opens keeps dead addresses on the list.
- **Suppress, don't delete.** Soft suppression stops the sends but keeps the history, so a returning shopper can re-enter through a flow.
- **Some people skip the queue.** Hard bounces and spam reporters come off after one. Klaviyo drops soft bounces after more than 7 in a row; take chronic ones off at 3-5.
- **Look beyond email.** Someone who ignores email but browses weekly or buys in store is not dead.
- **Give the win-back a purchase exit** (“Placed Order zero times since starting this flow”) and a real lapse window. It opens on your best offer, so without both, active customers learn to wait for it.

For regular campaigns, many agencies mail a 90-day engaged segment and keep the full eligible list for one or two big moments a month, such as a launch or a last call. Size that segment by the revenue and orders it brings, not by its open rate. The [list health guide](/blog/email-list-health-numbers) covers the numbers to read after every send.

## Why did opens, clicks or revenue suddenly drop?

Work from delivery up. A fall in revenue can start with placement, and a fall in opens may be no problem at all, since privacy opens make the open rate noisy.

| Layer | Question | What to check |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Delivery | Is the mail arriving? | Authentication, Postmaster Tools compliance, bounces, complaints, results by inbox provider |
| Engagement | Are people clicking as before? | Privacy and bot opens, who the send went to, the offer, tracking |
| Conversion | Are orders and revenue per delivered email holding? | Volume, product mix, order value, the path to checkout |

1. **Check the setup.** SPF, DKIM and DMARC still pass, and Postmaster Tools shows you compliant. A DNS change elsewhere can break a setup that worked last month.
2. **Read your flows as a tripwire.** The first welcome and abandoned cart emails reach people who just acted and tend to open at about 50% or more. Well below that, check placement before copy; near 20%, plan a full re-warm.
3. **Break the send down by inbox provider.** If one collapses while the others hold, often after mailing an old list, exclude its addresses from campaigns, send everyone else the 30-day engaged segment, and bring that provider back gradually, most engaged first.
4. **Run a seed test** with a tool such as GlockApps or Mail-Tester, which estimates placement from a sample: 75%+ inbox is healthy, 60-75% needs attention, below 60% is serious.
5. **Tighten, then rebuild.** Send only to engaged segments until a re-test recovers. Below 50% inbox, restart warming at 200-500 recently engaged profiles over 8-12 weeks; full recovery takes 60-90 days of clean sending.

Two moves don't help. No subject line beats a damaged reputation. And a fresh domain is a last resort: practitioners switch only after long failed rebuilds, and even then it guarantees nothing.

## If you run email for clients

Run the setup check on every new client before the first campaign. Read Klaviyo's acceptable-use policy, and the SMS provider's, before taking on a brand in a restricted category or sending another company's offers: a breach can pause sending or close the account. And keep each client's consent proof in that client's account.

This week, look up your SPF, DKIM and DMARC records, check that your From address sits on your sending domain, and build the suppression segment you'll review each month. Then turn to who joins the list in the first place, the subject of the next chapter: [how to grow an email list of people who buy](/blog/grow-an-email-list-that-buys).

## How to authenticate and warm up a new sending domain in Klaviyo

1. **Add a branded sending domain**: In Klaviyo, open Settings, then Domains, add a subdomain of your site with dynamic routing, and add the generated NS records at your DNS provider.
2. **Publish DMARC at p=none**: Add a TXT record at _dmarc with a reporting address you read, then watch the reports for 2-4 weeks.
3. **Fix the From and reply-to**: Send from an address on your root domain and point the reply-to at an inbox a person reads.
4. **Turn on flows first**: Go live with the first welcome, abandoned cart and abandoned checkout emails before any campaign.
5. **Ramp up campaigns**: Start with about 500 engaged profiles and double the audience every 2-3 sends over 4-8 weeks, holding if complaints pass 0.1%.
6. **Enforce DMARC**: Move to p=quarantine, then p=reject, once the reports show every legitimate sender passing.

## FAQ

### Why are my emails going to spam?

Usually one of three things: missing or misaligned SPF, DKIM or DMARC, a spam complaint rate creeping toward 0.3%, or campaigns going to people who stopped engaging long ago. Check authentication first, then complaints, then who your campaigns target.

### Do I need DMARC if I send fewer than 5,000 emails a day?

Set it up anyway. It's one DNS record, p=none meets the Gmail, Yahoo and Microsoft minimum, and once you send 5,000 in a day to Gmail addresses, Google treats you as a bulk sender from then on.

### How long does it take to warm up a new sending domain?

Plan on 4-8 weeks. Start with about 500 of your most engaged profiles and double the audience every 2-3 sends, as long as complaints stay under 0.1% and clicks hold.

### Is a customer who bought from me subscribed to marketing email?

No. A purchase covers order and shipping messages; marketing needs a separate opt-in. The UK and EU allow a narrow soft opt-in for existing customers, so check with counsel before relying on it.

### How often should I clean my email list?

Monthly. Suppress hard bounces and spam reporters at once, send a sunset email to anyone with no clicks, site visits or orders in 180 days after at least five emails, and suppress whoever doesn't respond within 7-14 days.

---

Source: Wizel (https://www.wizel.ai/blog/email-deliverability-and-consent)
Last updated: 2026-11-19